Affiliate links may appear below. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. General information, not medical advice.
Androstadienone and estratetraenol have formidable names and a modest evidence base. Both have been studied as possible human chemical signals. Neither has been established as a human pheromone, and a finding in a laboratory does not tell you what happens when someone wears a scented product.
The distinction matters. A brain scan, a saliva sample and a judgment about a face each answer a different question. None is a test of whether a cologne changes someone else’s feelings about its wearer.
What are AND and EST?
Researchers often shorten androstadienone to AND and estratetraenol to EST. AND is a steroid found in human sweat, including men’s sweat. EST is an estrogen-like steroid studied as a possible counterpart. They are candidate compounds, not confirmed signals with a known effect on human behavior.
Calling a molecule a pheromone requires more than showing that people respond to it somehow. In his 2015 review, biologist Tristram Wyatt describes a sequence: show a repeatable response to a natural secretion, identify the active molecule, then show that the isolated or synthesized molecule produces that response. He found no robust evidence from that sequence for the four steroid candidates often called human pheromones, including AND and EST. That leaves room for human chemical communication; it does not validate these particular ingredients.
What the early experiments measured
In a 2001 PET imaging study, Ivanka Savic and colleagues reported different patterns of hypothalamic activation when women smelled an androgen-like compound and men smelled an estrogen-like compound. The hypothalamus is involved in many functions, so the result was intriguing. The paper proposed a possible basis for a sex-differentiated response. It did not measure attraction, product wear or a social encounter. A visible brain response cannot, on its own, tell us what a person will feel or do.
A 2007 experiment led by Claire Wyart exposed women to pure AND and measured salivary cortisol. The authors reported that cortisol remained higher after AND exposure than after a control odor. Their paper also reported changes in some mood measures. This was a controlled exposure to a single compound, not a trial of a finished fragrance. The finding does not show that a diluted ingredient in cologne has the same effect.
These papers are worth reading because they specify what was measured. A cortisol result is a physiological observation. A PET signal is a brain imaging observation. Neither establishes that AND or EST is a pheromone, much less that a bottle can influence another person.
What the null study tested
Robin Hare and colleagues published a double-blind study in 2017 that tested predictions about both compounds. Participants completed computer-based tasks on two days, with a control scent on one day and AND or EST on the other. In one task, 46 people classified ambiguous faces by gender. In another, 94 rated photos of opposite-sex faces for attractiveness and probable unfaithfulness.
Exposure had no measured effect on those judgments. The study directly challenges claims that AND and EST reliably change these particular face perceptions. It was still a laboratory study using photographs, not a test of conversations, dates or cologne. Its null result cannot prove that either compound has no effect in any circumstance.
That precision cuts both ways. The positive studies cannot be stretched into a promise about attraction; the null study cannot settle every possible question about human scent. Together, they give little reason to treat a perfume label’s pheromone claim as a demonstrated social effect.
Why a positive result is not a product promise
Wyatt’s review points to recurring problems in this literature: small samples, effects that may be overstated, publication bias and limited replication. There is also a basic gap between the experimental material and the bottle on a shelf. Researchers control the compound and exposure. A fragrance combines ingredients, has its own odor, and is worn at varying amounts in ordinary places. The studies above did not test a retail formula.
Nor must a chemosignal be completely undetectable to matter. Ordinary smell is a plausible route for human scent perception. If a participant can smell a test material, though, its odor and the context of the test become part of interpreting the result. A claim that the effect is an invisible, automatic signal needs evidence for that specific mechanism.
No human pheromone has been conclusively identified. That is a statement about the evidence so far, not a claim that people never respond to one another’s scent. Fragrance has an ordinary appeal: you can smell it, choose it and decide how it fits your day.
How to read the bottle
If a maker names AND or EST, you have an ingredient to look up. You do not have proof that the finished product will affect anyone else. If a maker says only “pheromone blend,” even the ingredients are unclear. Neither label tells you how the fragrance smells after an hour on your skin.
Start there instead. Try a sample when possible, give it time to settle, and notice whether you enjoy wearing it. A pleasant scent is something you can judge for yourself; an effect on a stranger is a claim that needs much stronger evidence. For the larger scientific question, see do human pheromones work?. For the basics of chemical signaling, read what are pheromones?. Our pheromone cologne versus regular cologne guide explains how to compare the bottles themselves.
Buy a fragrance because you like how it smells. The research on AND and EST is interesting; the promised effect on somebody else remains unproven.
Questions
Is androstadienone a proven human pheromone?
No. Researchers have reported brain and cortisol responses in controlled experiments, but no study has established it as a human pheromone or shown that a fragrance containing it changes social behavior.
What did the estratetraenol studies find?
A 2001 brain imaging study reported a response to an estrogen-like compound in men. A separate 2017 experiment found no effect of estratetraenol or androstadienone on its tested face judgments. Neither result establishes a pheromone.
Should I buy a pheromone cologne?
Choose it if you like the fragrance. Claims that added compounds change how other people respond to you lack convincing evidence.
Sources
- Savic I et al. (2001). Smelling of odorous sex hormone-like compounds causes sex-differentiated hypothalamic activations in humans. Neuron 31:661-668.
- Wyart C et al. (2007). Smelling a single component of male sweat alters levels of cortisol in women. J Neurosci 27:1261-1265.
- Hare RM et al. (2017). Putative sex-specific human pheromones do not affect gender perception, attractiveness ratings or unfaithfulness judgements of opposite sex faces. R Soc Open Sci 4:160831.
- Wyatt TD (2015). The search for human pheromones: the lost decades and the necessity of returning to first principles. Proc R Soc B 282:20142994.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How we pick.
